Costello Bakehouse

Luxury Cheesecakes, Handcrafted to Impress

Discover our handcrafted collection of premium cheesecakes, baked fresh to order using the finest ingredients. From timeless classics to our signature gourmet creations, every cheesecake is made to be the centerpiece of your celebration.

Shop cheesecakes Explore the collection

Our signature collection

Made to Be the Centerpiece

Beautifully decorated, generously portioned, and made for birthdays, gatherings, gifts, and every moment worth celebrating.

View all cheesecakes
Create Your Own Cheesecake
Create Your Own Cheesecake
$85.00 View details →
Classic New York Cheesecake
Classic New York Cheesecake
$55.00 View details →
Knafeh Cheesecake
Knafeh Cheesecake
$65.00 View details →
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
$65.00 View details →
Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Cheesecake
$65.00 View details →
Dubai Cheesecake
Dubai Cheesecake
$65.00 View details →
Biscoff Cheesecake
Biscoff Cheesecake
$65.00 View details →
Coconut Cheesecake
Coconut Cheesecake
$65.00 View details →

The Costello difference

Crafted With Care, Served With Pride

✦

Premium Ingredients

Only carefully selected ingredients for rich flavor and a smooth, luxurious texture.

♡

Handcrafted Fresh

Every cheesecake is made in small batches with care, precision, and attention to detail.

◇

Made for Celebrations

A beautiful centerpiece for birthdays, holidays, family gatherings, gifts, and special occasions.

The signature sampler

Can’t Choose Just One?

Experience ten signature flavors in one unforgettable cheesecake, including Strawberry, Blueberry, White Chocolate Raspberry, Coconut, Biscoff, Nutella, Pistachio, Dubai, Cookies & Cream, and Cannoli.

Discover the sampler

Our story

Baked for the Moments That Bring Us Together.

At Costello Bakehouse, every cheesecake begins with a passion for quality and craftsmanship. From our buttery graham cracker crusts to our carefully selected toppings, every detail is made to turn ordinary moments into lasting memories.

Our story

Loved by our customers

A Dessert They’ll Remember

★★★★★
“The best cheesecake we have ever had.”
Verified customer
★★★★★
“Every guest asked where we bought it.”
Verified customer
★★★★★
“Beautiful presentation and unbelievable flavor.”
Verified customer

Make the moment sweeter

Every Celebration Deserves Something Extraordinary.

Choose your favorite cheesecake and let Costello Bakehouse create the centerpiece for your next celebration.

Order your cheesecake

Best Sellers

View all

Fruit collection

Signature collection