Create Your Own

Build Your
Split Decision

Why choose just one? Select two of your favorite Costello Bakehouse flavors and we'll bring them together in one unforgettable cheesecake.
1 FIRST HALF
2 SECOND HALF
Choose two flavors to build your cheesecake

Two Favorites. One Unforgettable Cheesecake.

Split Decision Cheesecake

★★★★★ Loved by our customers
$85.00
Can’t decide? Choose two of your favorite flavors and enjoy them together in one handcrafted half-and-half cheesecake.
✓
10-inch cheesecake • Approximately 12 slices
✓
Handcrafted fresh to order
✓
Premium ingredients
✓
Local pickup and delivery options
01
02
YOUR SPLIT DECISION Select your two flavors
Quantity
Secure checkout • Freshly made to order
Ingredients +

Ingredients vary depending on the selected assortment. Please refer to each featured flavor for complete ingredient information.

Storage +

Keep refrigerated upon arrival. Best enjoyed within 5 days. Freeze for up to 2 months if wrapped securely.

Serving +

Allow 20–30 minutes at room temperature before serving. Includes multiple signature flavors for sharing.

Pickup & Delivery +

Fresh pickup is available by appointment. Local delivery is available throughout select Central Florida areas.

Allergen Notice +

Contains milk, eggs, wheat, and may contain soy, peanuts, tree nuts, and coconut depending on the flavors included.