Holiday Pre-Orders
Holiday Pre-Orders Are Open
Make your holiday table unforgettable with a handcrafted Costello Bakehouse cheesecake — baked fresh to order for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Pre-order now and let us handle dessert.
Thanksgiving
Order by: Sunday, November 22
Pickup / Delivery: Wednesday, November 25 — the day before Thanksgiving
Christmas
Order by: Sunday, December 20
Pickup / Delivery: Wednesday, December 23
How It Works
- Choose your cheesecake — pick from our Holiday Pre-Orders collection, including seasonal favorites like Pumpkin and classics like New York and Strawberry.
- Check out — select local delivery at checkout.
- We bake & deliver fresh — your cheesecake arrives in time for the holiday: $30 delivery within 25 miles of Oakland, FL, or $50 for 25–50 miles.
Holiday baking slots are limited — once our schedule fills up, pre-orders close. Order early to guarantee your dessert.
